International Open Access Journal Platform

“陈寿元效应违背自然规律” 与审查专家对话

Dialogue between “Chen Shouyuan Effect Goes against the Laws of Nature” and Censors

Advance in Law / 2021,3(2): 68-81 / 2021-04-23 678 1147

View Download PDF

• Authors: 陈寿元     
• Information:

  山东师范大学信息科学与工程学院，济南
  摘

• Keywords: Patent application; Chen Shouyuan effect; Patent law; Patent search guide; Science and technology; Invention and discovery 专利申请,陈寿元效应,专利法,专利查指南,科学与技术,发明与发现
• Abstract: This paper first introduces a series of patent applications based on Chen Shouyuan effect (about 7 cases), all of which were rejected on the grounds that Chen Shouyuan effect violated the laws of nature. The examination is based on the clause of "Patent Examination Guide: 2-5-3.22, Application violates the laws of nature. Four textbooks, Physics, Edited by Liu Yongsheng, Tsinghua University Publishing House, are listed to draw a conclusion. The inventor questioned the review opinions and reconsideration decisions from three angles. (1) whether the examination process violates the patent law and whether the examination authority exceeds the examination scope stipulated by the patent law. (2) Whether the Chen Shouyuan effect violates the laws of nature. (3) Whether the series of applications based on Chen Shouyuan effect meet the authorization conditions of patent law. Dialogue with patent examination experts on the above three issues. 该文首先介绍基于陈寿元效应的系列专利申请（约有7 件），皆被以陈寿元效应违背自然规律为由驳回。审查依据“专利审查指南：2-5-3.22，申请违背自然规律”条款。并列出《物理，刘永胜编，清华大学出版社》等四本教材为据得出结论。发明人对审查意见、复议决定提出质疑：（1）审查流程是否违背专利法、审查权限是否超出专利法规定的审查范围；（2）陈寿元效应多学科符合自然规律的解释；（3）基于陈寿元效应的系列申请满足专利法的授权条件。就以上三个问题与专利审查专家展开对话。。
• DOI: https://doi.org/10.35534/al.0302008
• Cite: 陈寿元．“陈寿元效应违背自然规律”与审查专家对话［J］．法学进展，2021，3（2）：68-81．