International Open Access Journal Platform

司法与网络民意关系之辨析——以“江歌案”与“药家鑫案”为例

Analysis of the Relationship between Judicature and Network Public Opinion —Take“Jiang Ge Case” and“Yao Jiaxin Case” for Example

Advance in Law / 2025,7(1): 23-34 / 2024-12-20 246 161

View Download PDF

• Authors: 魏欣然     
• Information:

  上海政法学院，上海

• Keywords: Network public opinion; Judicature; Judicial independence; Harmonious judicature 网络民意；司法；司法独立；和谐司法
• Abstract: “Jiang Ge case” and“Yao Jiaxin case” are two typical cases in which public opinion on the Internet has a certain impact on the judiciary. The attitude of Internet public opinion towards the two cases reflects the difference between law and morality, and the importance of the principle of judicial independence in judicial activities. This paper tries to find a balance mechanism between Internet public opinion and judicature by comparing and analyzing the different views of internet public opinion and legal person in the two cases and the causes of public opinion in China and Japan. In the framework of harmonious judicature, we can realize the harmonious coexistence of network public opinion and judicature by means of improving judicial credibility, absorbing public opinion reasonably and establishing good spirit of rule of law. 本文以“江歌案”与“药家鑫案”为研究对象，分析了网络民意对司法判决的影响。文章指出，网络民意在两案中的态度揭示了法律与道德的张力，以及司法独立原则在司法实践中的重要性。本文通过对两案网络民意与法律人不同观点，以及中日两国民意产生原因的比较分析，致力于求得网络民意与司法之间的平衡机制。并最终认为在和谐司法的框架下，运用提高司法公信力、合理吸收民意以及树立优良的法治精神三种举措，能够实现网络民意与司法的和谐共存。
• DOI: https://doi.org/10.35534/al.0701003
• Cite: 魏欣然．司法与网络民意关系之辨析——以“江歌案”与“药家鑫案”为例［J］．法学进展，2025，7（1）：23-34.